Thank you to @ladyteal for getting our list of shows started! This is the official post where I will update a running list of recommended shows by members of Slightly Sinister! Open each catagory for a full list of recommendations within each category I will be trolling the posts for more recs. below, so keep em' coming!
Mind-Bending Shows
Dark
The OA
Yellow Jackets
A Murder at the End of the World
Another Earth
Sound of My Voice
East
The Recordist
The Twilight Zone
Sci-Fi
Horror
Supernatural Themes
Fantasy
Murder Mystery
Historical Fiction/Fantasy
Keep sending recommendations and the categories you want added to the list! I added a handful to keep up the momentum. Feel free to visit the other recommendation forum pages and get started there as well!
def need to add Yellow Jackets to the Dark list. I have seen nearly every show on your list and this one is the most twisted I have seen. Haunting of hill house and Bly Manor as well. Fantasy is Pans Labyrinth